For all things environmental in Western New York – news, events, outdoor places, and much more!

Home  >  The Blog  >  Filling Tires With Nitrogen: Just a Bunch of Hot Air?

The Blog

Filling Tires With Nitrogen: Just a Bunch of Hot Air?

green_capHave you ever noticed the green valve caps on other people’s tires in the parking lot? I have, and I always wondered where they got them. Turns out, these people have paid to fill their vehicle’s tires with nitrogen instead of oxygen.  Nitrogen is thought to increase gas mileage, but I was skeptical about this. I did some digging and found this myth is plagued with technicalities.

Technically, proper tire inflation is what increases your car’s fuel mileage. The reason nitrogen allegedly increases your gas mileage is because it keeps your tires fuller longer. Nitrogen’s molecular design is bigger than oxygen, making it harder for this gas to escape from your tires (see diagram below). Pure nitrogen also helps to keep water vapor out of your tires, which helps to prevent corrosion of the wheel and a breakdown of the interior rubber. You will pay more for Nitrogen, which is why many people view it as a gimmick to get people to spend their money. So the question becomes, is it worth it?

molecule_sizeSome fact checking done by BankRate.com, a free website helping people make educated economic decisions, states the damage done by water vapor in your tire is questionable due to the fact that most tire treads wear down faster than any internal damage could occur. Additionally, the website says most of the air lost from a tire comes from a leak, or the tire not properly lining up with the rim, not from it leaking through the rubber. This information left me questioning the benefits of nitrogen even more. I reminded myself to break this myth down to the basics.

The nitrogen isn’t the key to great gas mileage; maintaining proper tire inflation is. Whether you fill your tires with normal air from the gas station, or nitrogen from a dealership, if they aren’t filled properly you won’t be getting the most out of your tires. The nitrogen has been introduced to help people maintain the proper tire pressure, which helps the car run well and be more fuel-efficient. If you avidly check your tire pressure, then maybe nitrogen isn’t for you. But, if you don’t know how to check your tires, maybe nitrogen is the way to go. The choice is up to you.

Do you think nitrogen or oxygen would best suit your driving habits? Tell us in our comment section below.

 

3 Comments

  1. Pluleeze, a bit of science might be in order. What you are talking about is the diffusion rate of N2 versus that of the oxygen in air (about 21% by volume, the rest being N2 and a bit of argon). The Pure N2 used is also anhydrous while most compressed air has whatever water vapor was present in the air that was compressed. All polymers (and the rubber in tires is a mix of elastomer polymers and inert fillers like carbon black) are permeable to gases, but it depends on the polymers and gasses, and the pressure of the gas determines the diffusion rate.

    For molecular size, see http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_does_the_size_of_a_nitrogen_molecule_compare_to_that_of_oxygen. You could also use argon, but this is just a status thing, and a waste of money for those who have money to waste...8-)
  2. Thank you for that insight Dave; the more science to clear up this myth the better! Like you said, any gas can permeate the polymers that make up our car tires, so that debunks the claim that your tires will leak less with nitrogen. Nitrogen is often sold to people in order to increase their gas mileage under the assumption that it keeps your tires fuller longer. It is not the nitrogen impacting the gas mileage, it is the proper tire inflation. People should be checking their tire pressures regardless of what gas fills their tires, and maintaing the proper pressure to be rewarded at the pump.
  3. Thanks for clearing this up. My front tires leak a lot anyway (may need new valve stems). That's the next thing I will have checked, since I already had the rims cleaned.

      • >:o
      • :-[
      • :'(
      • :-(
      • :-D
      • :-*
      • :-)
      • :P
      • :\
      • 8-)
      • ;-)



    • Click to get a new image.